Friday, January 16, 2009

Corporal Punishment Nightmare

One of my worst nightmares occurred at our last Board of Education meeting last Tuesday.

A young lady came to speak before the board concerning some issues she had with the principal at her school. As she was explaining her dilemma withe the school principal*, she informed the board that her child was paddled by the principal (or assistant). This kind of punishment is perfectly legal under Alabama law as noted in a previous post.

The problem with this one is that this mother claims that there was a note in the child's personal file that he shall not be paddled. If that note is in there then my school system has not only inflicted physical harm upon a small child, it has also opened itself up to litigation.

This kind of situation opens up a whole slew of uncomfortable scenarios. Now, as far as I know, the child in question at this board meeting is from a perfectly normal, no-abusive family. BUT, what if this child was a victim of some sort of physical abuse? What if the mom didn't want him paddled because he had endured years of therapy and a single paddling might set him back years?

Does the state have a right to further inflict physical harm upon a child that is used to receiving beatings? Of course not!

*Note that I am certain the administration is doing everything they can to accomodate this young woman's concerns.

No comments: